Small businesses across Canada are dealing with a growing trend in the hiring process: being ghosted by job candidates and new hires. More than one-third of small business owners said they’ve hired people who never showed up or stopped coming into work shortly after starting (36%) and/or had job candidates who stopped responding during the application or interview process in the past 12 months (37%), according to a new survey by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB).
“Employers are already having an incredibly hard time filling certain positions. Ghosting is not only a frustrating waste of their time, it’s a big drain on their already limited resources,” said Dan Kelly, President at CFIB. “Job candidates and employees don’t have to take or stay in jobs they don’t like, but they should at least communicate their intentions clearly to their employer instead of leaving them scrambling and wondering.”
Skilled or semi-/unskilled labour shortages continue to limit business growth for 53% and 38% of businesses, respectively, according to the latest CFIB Business Barometer. Over half (52%) of small businesses have yet to return to normal revenue levels and 58% haven’t repaid their pandemic debt, according to CFIB’s Small Business Recovery Dashboard.
As the federal government is working on potential reforms to the Employment Insurance (EI) system, CFIB is urging Ottawa to take into consideration the impact of potential EI changes on small businesses.
“We’re hearing from business owners who have experienced ghosting that some candidates prefer to stay on EI for as long as possible and may be applying for or taking jobs just to satisfy the requirements of the program,” added Kelly. “While the vast majority of EI recipients may be looking for work in good faith, any changes the government is considering making to the program should not disincentivize people from accepting or starting jobs, especially with the current labour shortages we’re experiencing.”
CFIB recommends the federal government not implement any permanent changes to the EI system until the economy has fully recovered. This includes:
- Not making coverage for the self-employed mandatory as it could have significant cost implications for many small businesses
- Undertaking a full and detailed costs analysis of all expansion proposals and laying out a plan to ensure EI remains sustainable without imposing any new costs on employers
“EI is supposed to serve as a temporary relief measure for people facing an unexpected job loss or in between jobs. Now is not the time to make permanent changes to the EI system that would increase the cost of doing business or disincentivize people from working. Small businesses still need time to get back on their feet,” said Corinne Pohlmann, Senior Vice-President of National Affairs at CFIB. “Employers across all provinces and sectors are experiencing labour shortages, and any changes to the EI program should not exacerbate them.”
Your Voice – November 2022: An online survey completed by 3,264 CFIB members between November 10-28, 2022. For comparison purposes, a probability sample with the same number of respondents would have a margin of error of ±1.7 per cent, 19 times out of 20.